Retaliatory Actions In Healthcare: What Are They?

A jury rendered a $1 million verdict in favor of Dr. Margarita Gormus on her retaliation claim against Greystone Park Psychiatric Hospital in New Jersey.

The claim arose out of Dr. Gormus' testimony in a class action regarding a patient's demise in 2018. Greystone paid a large settlement as a result of the class action, which included significant changes in staffing and security policies at the hospital.

Dr. Gormus alleged that, in an act of retaliation, her superior began assigning her twice the number of patients - ultimately - 52 total. Many of these patients were also considered violent and dangerous. The jury found this added workload after Gormus' testimony in the class action amounted to retaliation.

Source: https://patch.com/new-jersey/morris/doctor-awarded-1m-after-exposing-embattled-nj-psych-facility

Commentary

Those who testify must be protected from retaliatory actions. A retaliatory action - defined as a materially adverse action - can include:

· Demotions

· Wage reductions

· Ostracization

· Work location changes

· Reduced benefits

· Promotion denials

· Changes in working conditions

· Increased workloads

· Work-related threats, warnings, or reprimands

· Negative or lowered evaluations

· Transfers to undesirable work locations

· Micro-managing without justification

· Removing supervisory responsibilities

· Subjecting the employee to abusive language

· Threats of deportation

· Taking a materially-adverse action against a family member

· Threatening a civil action

Healthcare employers may help reduce the risk by considering the following:

· Be vigilant after an employee testifies to make sure no negative employment actions are taken without proper contemporaneous documentation

· The documentation should indicate the business-related reason for any change in a complainant's workload, duties, schedule, pay, etc. independent of the outcome of the investigation the employee participated in

· Make sure your supervisors are trained to consult with HR before changing any terms or conditions of employment

Finally, your opinion is important to us. Please complete the opinion survey:

Product

Articles

Retaliatory Actions In Healthcare: What Are They?

A New Jersey hospital must pay $1 million to a former physician for retaliation after she testified in a class action. We examine this case and retaliatory actions.

Unilateral Access To Funds Leads To Multi-Million Dollar Embezzlement?

A private equity fund manager was able to embezzle more than $11 million through bypassing the investment committee. We discuss the importance of committee oversight to help prevent fraud.

AI Malware May Be The New Hot Scam, But Don't Forget The Classics

AI has been getting much media attention in the cybersecurity sphere; however, the cyber attack basics are still legitimate risks, and they are not going away. We discuss those risks and what organizations need to know.

How Exclusion And Ultimatums To Whistleblowers Support Charges Of Retaliation

A health system is sued by an employee, who alleged she was excluded and given an ultimatum after reporting compliance concerns. We comment on the risks healthcare employers create when they isolate employees instead of conducting an investigation.

Poor Vendor Email Security Creates Huge Risk

An Atlanta children's charity suffers a $5 million loss after an attacker used a trusted vendor's email to request a payment information change. We discuss how vendor email compromise and poor internal controls can combine to create sizeable risks.