Healthcare Employers And Avoiding The Retaliation Trap

A former research director, Traci Tamiko Eto, sued the Mayo Clinic and alleged she was demoted, and then fired, after raising concerns about AI oversight on research projects.

Eto filed a discrimination and retaliation charge with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, received a right-to-sue letter, and then filed her lawsuit.

According to the allegations in the lawsuit, Eto identified multiple lapses in compliance with federal research standards at the health system. These lapses included bypassing institutional review board review, mishandling patient data, and authorizing a cardiac surgical device procedure that had not gone through an institutional review board.

Additionally, a 2024 study of the digital assistant tool, MAYA, used by the health system, revealed the tool outcomes were mischaracterized, unfavorable results were deleted, and unauthorized software was utilized.

According to Eto's allegations, researchers allegedly attempted to conceal a 67 percent MAYA error rate, but the study was ultimately approved and did not require inspections, despite ten separate whistleblower reports.

Eto alleged she reported concerns to the health system's legal department, after which she claimed she was excluded from leadership meetings and told she could resign on her own or face professional consequences.

Shortly after, Eto was placed on a corrective action plan, which she challenged. She alleged that there was no meaningful investigation into her challenge.

Further, Eto was allegedly demoted and her request for medical leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act was denied before ultimately being approved after she retained an attorney.

While on leave, Eto received a notification that her job was being eliminated. She was ultimately terminated after applying for several different internal positions. Eto claims she was flagged in an internal "ghost file" at the health system which flags former employees who raised concerns as "Not Eligible for Rehire".

Source: https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/healthcare-information-technology/ai/mayo-faces-lawsuit-over-ai-oversight-retaliation/

Commentary

Retaliation has historically been, and continues to be, the most frequently filed charge with the EEOC.
https://www.eeoc.gov/data/enforcement-and-litigation-statistics-0

It occurs when an organization takes adverse action against an employee for engaging in protected activities, including reporting harassment, discrimination, illegal actions, safety violations, regulatory breaches, etc.

Retaliation continues to be common because it is a separate legal cause of action, independent from the underlying claim. And, it can survive whether the underlying claim succeeds or fails.

So long as the employee had a good faith, reasonable belief that the conduct they reported or opposed was unlawful, employers must refrain from retaliatory responses.

In healthcare settings, that reporting may be regarding fraud, patient safety violations, regulatory breaches, and more. For example, in the above case, the employee alleged violations of federal research standards, mishandling of patient data, unauthorized procedures, and use of an AI tool in use that allegedly had an error rate of nearly 70 percent.

The final takeaway is retaliation claims are always cause for concern. The best way for healthcare organizations to avoid the risks is to review all contemplated negative employment actions thoroughly before implementing them against employees who have blown the whistle.

Finally, your opinion is important to us. Please complete the opinion survey:

Product

Articles

Healthcare Employers And Avoiding The Retaliation Trap

A Mayo Clinic employee alleged she faced retaliation after complaining about lapses in compliance with federal standards. We discuss why retaliation claims continue to be so dangerous and what may help avoid them.

Embezzlement Red Flags - Self-Approval Of Expenses For Reimbursement

An accounting executive at an NBA team is sentenced in connection with a $3.7 million embezzlement scheme involving his approval of his own expenses for reimbursement. Learn the risks of allowing expense self-review and approval.

The Microsoft Teams Scam That Is Tricking Workers: Learn The Details And The Risks

A new scam, which leverages Microsoft Teams, is targeting employers and employees. Learn more about the risk.

The Limitations Of The Independent Contractor Defense For Healthcare Whistleblowers

An anesthesiologist won a whistleblower lawsuit against an Oregon surgical center. The center tried to argue he was never an employee. We discuss what healthcare organizations need to know about misclassification risks.

What Do You Know About Travel Expense Fraud? And, What Could It Be Costing You?

An employee is accused of using school credit cards for personal travel and event expenses. We discuss how some wrongdoers hide their fraud in plain sight within travel expenses.